PhysWallThe Physical-Logic Gateway

Twenty-eight domains, and four of them are not physics

A physics engine, and a verification tool enforced on top of it. PhysWall inverts a closed, published, non-linear physical law at a single measurement point — and refuses when the inverse is not unique. Seven laws, one engine, and the same refusal in all of them.

Twenty-eight domains. 16 of them can tell you a number is impossible, 9 can tell you this law does not govern your case — and four of them are not physics at all.

This page is a list, and it is also the argument. The claim is not that we know twenty-eight laws. It is that twenty-eight different things fit the same shape, so a reader gets the same three answers whichever one fires.

Every figure below is counted from the extension's own files when this page is built. None of them is typed. A page about counts is the worst place to keep a second copy of them.

What each one can actually do

Filled — can say a number is impossible. Ringed — can say so with nothing asked of you. Plain — can only say what is missing. Dashed — no closed law yet.

16of 28

carry a ceiling, so they can contradict the answer. 2 of those need nothing from you at all — the limit is a published constant and the number either clears it or does not.

12of 28

have no ceiling to compare against, so they name what is missing instead. This is the common case and it is the useful one. Most numbers a model gives you are not impossible. They are unverifiable, which is a different thing and nobody says it.

And four of them are not physics

This is the part worth stopping on. It reads like a caveat and it is the opposite.

LawDomainField
Amdahl 1967Parallel speed-up against the serial fractioncomputing
Miller & Sanjurjo 2018Streak, or sample sizestatistics
Nyquist 1928, Shannon 1949Sampling rate against bandwidthinformation theory
Wilson 1927Is this percentage distinguishablestatistics

A confidence interval and a heat engine have nothing in common. They sit in the same row, with the same fields, and produce the same three verdicts. Nothing in the scanner knows which is which.

Thermodynamics

needs
turbine inlet, stack, ambient
says
an efficiency with no stack temperature cannot tell a combined cycle from a simple one
source
Carnot 1824

Statistics

needs
the number of trials
says
a percentage with no count behind it has no range — 52.9% on 17 attempts sits anywhere from 31% to 74%
source
Wilson 1927

That is why it works, and it is the only interesting claim on this page. Adding a domain is a row, not a project. The twenty-ninth will behave like the first twenty-eight because nothing about the first twenty-eight is special-cased.

The exception, named

One of the twenty-eight has no published law behind it. The basketball release angle tells you what a shot angle would need before it can be judged, and there it stops. It is in the list because it does useful work; it is named here because a list that hides its weakest entry is not a list, it is a brochure.

All twenty-eight

DomainWhat it can saySource
Wind turbine power coefficientsays it is impossible, with nothing asked of youBetz 1919
Single-junction solar cell efficiencysays it is impossible, with nothing asked of youShockley & Queisser 1961
Diffraction limit on resolutionsays it is impossibleAbbe 1873
Parallel speed-up against the serial fractionsays it is impossibleAmdahl 1967
Battery specific energy against its chemistrysays it is impossibleAbraham, J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 6:830, 2015, Eq. 5 and Tables 2–3 · Li–S 2,600 Wh/kg of sulfur from McCreary et al., Batteries 7:82, 2021
Heat-engine efficiencysays it is impossibleCarnot 1824
Heat pump coefficient of performancesays it is impossibleCarnot 1824
Trace length against a loss budgetsays it is impossibleconductor and dielectric loss, standard form
Dielectric loss factorsays it is impossibledielectric loss, standard form
Radiation Q for a small antennasays it is impossibleWheeler 1947, Chu 1948, Pascale 2021
Minimum energy to erase a bitsays it is impossibleLandauer 1961
Channel discharge from stagesays it is impossibleManning 1889
Sampling rate against bandwidthsays it is impossibleNyquist 1928, Shannon 1949
Photosynthetic solar-to-biomass efficiencysays it is impossibleZhu, Long & Ort, Annu. Rev. Plant Biol. 61:235, 2010 · 4.6% C3 and 6.0% C4 on incident solar at 30 °C and 387 ppm CO2
Shannon-Hartley channel capacitysays it is impossibleShannon, Proc. IRE 37(1):10, 1949, Theorem 2 — "it is not possible by any encoding method to send at a higher rate and have an arbitrarily low frequency of errors"
Rocket delta-v against mass ratiosays it is impossibleTsiolkovsky 1903
Distance from round-trip light timesays what is missingc is exact by definition since 1983
Activation energy from a ratesays what is missingArrhenius 1889
Speed climbing powersays what is missingwork against gravity, closed form
Return loss against load Qsays what is missingBode 1945, Fano 1950
Anapole disk radiussays what is missingfitted to seven published disks
Is this percentage distinguishablesays what is missingWilson 1927
Radiated power from temperaturesays what is missingStefan 1879, Boltzmann 1884
Streak, or sample sizesays what is missingMiller & Sanjurjo 2018
Thermal noise frequencysays what is missingkT/h
Which wave approximation appliessays what is missingAiry 1845
Peak wavelength from temperaturesays what is missingWien 1893, constant from CODATA 2018
Release angle and consistencysays what is missingno closed law here yet

24 physics, 4 not. 27 rest on a law somebody else published and named; one does not, and says so.